Most business websites don't fail dramatically. They fail quietly. The enquiry form stops sending emails and nobody notices. The phone number isn't tappable on mobile. The page loads slowly on a customer's phone in Bendigo or Newcastle, and they give up. Is your website losing you money? This free website audit checklist will help you find out in about an afternoon, without being technical. Work through each section, tick off what's fine and write down what isn't.
The short answer: your website is probably losing you money if it loads slowly on mobile, if its forms or phone links don't work reliably, if visitors can't quickly see what you do and how to contact you, if it lacks genuine trust signals, or if you can't measure where your enquiries come from. This checklist covers each of those.
How do you check if your website is too slow?
- Run your homepage and your most important service page through Google PageSpeed Insights. Look at the mobile result first.
- Check the Core Web Vitals report in Google Search Console, which is based on real visitors, not a lab test.
- Load your site on your own phone using mobile data, not Wi-Fi. Does the main content appear quickly? Does anything jump around as it loads?
- Look for oversized images, auto-playing videos and pop-ups that slow the first view.
If speed is a problem, it affects everything else on this list. We've written more about building fast websites on our web design page.
Does your website work properly on mobile?
- Is text readable without zooming?
- Are buttons big enough to tap easily, and spaced so people don't hit the wrong one?
- Is your phone number a tap-to-call link?
- Does the menu open, close and work on every page?
- Do forms work on a phone keyboard, with the right keyboard for email and phone fields?
- Is anything cut off, overlapping or scrolling sideways?
Are your enquiry forms and contact details actually working?
This is the most important section, and the one most often skipped.
- Submit every form yourself. Did the email arrive? Where did it go, and who reads that inbox?
- Check the spam folder of whoever receives enquiries.
- After submitting, does the visitor see a clear confirmation of what happens next?
- Are your phone number, email and address correct and identical everywhere on the site?
- If you use a booking system or chat widget, test it end to end.
- Are form fields reasonable? Every extra required field is another reason to give up.
Can visitors tell what you do within seconds?
- Does your homepage say, in plain language, what you do, who you do it for and where?
- Is there one obvious next step, such as call, book or get a quote, visible without scrolling?
- Does each service have its own page explaining what's involved?
- Is the copy about the customer's problem, or mostly about you?
- Are prices, or at least how pricing works, explained where appropriate?
Does your website build trust?
- Genuine reviews or testimonials from real, named customers, with permission. Never invented ones; they can breach Australian Consumer Law.
- Real photos of your team, premises and work, rather than generic stock images.
- Licences, accreditations and memberships relevant to your industry.
- Who you are: an about page with real people behind the business.
- An up-to-date look. A copyright year from years ago or broken pages suggest the business may not be active.
- A privacy policy, especially if you collect personal information or run ad tracking.
Can you measure where your enquiries come from?
- Is Google Analytics 4 installed and receiving data?
- Are form submissions and calls tracked as conversions, so you can see which channels produce enquiries?
- If you run ads, is conversion tracking set up in Google Ads and Meta?
- Is Google Search Console connected, so you can see which searches bring people to your site?
- Do you ask new customers how they found you?
Without tracking, you can't tell which marketing is working.
Are the SEO basics in place?
- Does every page have a unique title and meta description that describes it?
- Does each page use one clear main heading?
- Can your important pages be found in Google? Search "site:" followed by your domain to see what's indexed.
- Is there an XML sitemap submitted in Search Console?
- Are there broken links or pages returning errors?
- Does your site use HTTPS, with a padlock in the browser?
- Is your Google Business Profile complete and consistent with your website, if you serve local customers?
For a deeper look at search visibility, see our SEO service.
Is your website accessible to everyone?
Accessibility means people with disabilities, including those using screen readers, keyboard navigation or larger text, can use your site. It also tends to make a site clearer for everyone. The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) are the widely used standard. Quick checks you can do yourself:
- Do images have descriptive alt text, especially images that carry information?
- Is there enough contrast between text and background? Light grey text on white is a common problem.
- Can you move through the site and submit a form using only the Tab and Enter keys?
- Do links and buttons say what they do? "Book a consultation" beats "click here".
- Does the page still work if you zoom the text in your browser?
What should you fix first?
Prioritise by how directly each problem stops enquiries:
- Broken forms, phone links or contact details. Fix today.
- Missing tracking. Set it up now so you can measure everything else.
- Mobile problems and slow loading.
- Unclear messaging and missing calls to action.
- Trust signals and SEO basics.
Some of these you can fix yourself in an hour. Others, particularly speed and structural issues, may point to a site that needs rebuilding rather than patching.
How often should you audit your website?
Test your forms and contact details whenever the site changes, and at least every few months even if it doesn't. Run through the full checklist once or twice a year, and after any redesign, new plugin or change of hosting. Websites drift quietly.
Frequently asked questions
Is this website audit checklist really free?
Yes. Everything above uses free tools: PageSpeed Insights, Google Search Console, Google Analytics and your own phone. You don't need to pay anyone to work through it.
My website looks good. Can it still be losing money?
Yes. Design is only part of it. A good-looking site can still load slowly, hide its contact details on mobile or have a form that quietly stopped working.
Do I need a new website if I fail several checks?
Not necessarily. Many issues can be fixed on an existing site. If the problems are about speed and structure, though, a rebuild may be more cost-effective than ongoing patches.
How long does a website audit take?
Working through this checklist yourself takes a few hours. A professional audit goes deeper into technical, SEO and conversion issues.
Can you audit my website for me?
Yes. We're a Gold Coast-based team working with businesses Australia-wide. Book a free strategy call and we'll go through your site with you and explain what's worth fixing first.
